The purpose of this module is to show teachers how the dynamic features of geometry software such as the Geometer's Sketchpad can be used in geometry courses to demonstrate theorems, to foster experimentation, to support problem solving, and to encourage conjecture. Teachers will also learn new geometry content closely related to the geometry that is taught in high school. This module was developed at our MTL partner, Eastern Illinois University. Credit: 1 grad. sem. hr.
Common Core Standards for Mathemtical Practice that are emphasized include:
Dynamic Geometry with Geometer's Sketchpad was written by Peter Andrews of Eastern Illinois University during in 1997. It was edited by Tony Peressini in September 1998.
The purpose of this module is to show you how the dynamic features of geometry software such as the Geometer's Sketchpad can be used to illustrate theorems, to foster experimentation, to support problem solving, and to encourage conjecture.
Dynamic geometry software such as the Geometer's Sketchpad or Cabri II are very powerful packages that allow you to make accurate geometric constructions and then to manipulate either the initial objects or the constructed ones to examine which relationships in the configuration are coincidental and which are inherent in the constructions.
To be able to exploit these features in the classroom you do not need to be an expert with the software, but you do need some experience with the basic capabilities and you need to see some of the "tricks of the trade" that facilitate the creation of good demonstrations and projects. And, of course, no matter how good the software is, what you don't know you can't illustrate!
This module provides you with a good deal of experience examining and experimenting with dynamic sketches. You will also have the opportunity to imitate some of these and to create examples of your own. This is all done in the context of discussing interesting topics in geometry that are accessible to high school students. Some of them are results that are already standard in the curriculum and others are not.
A brief description of the actual work needed to complete the module follows.
All of the ingredients necessary to complete these steps are contained in the files that you will download for this module. Moreover, you can get help when you need it by e-mail to the mentor named in your welcome letter. The next section will explain how to get started.
In addition to the general requirements for participating in Math Teacher Link, this module also has the following requirement:
Copy of Geometer's Sketchpad. You can follow this link to get the Geometer's Sketchpad home page of Key Curriculum Press, the makers of the software. This page has information, resources and support for The Geometer's Sketchpad software.
You do not need to hand in any of the work described in these. On the other hand, we will be assuming, throughout this module, that you have the level of facility with Geometer's Sketchpad that any of these provide. You be familiar with:
For those with the prerequisite Geometer's Sketchpad experience, it is likely that it will require about 35 hours to complete the lessons. The time required for the classroom project will depend on the size and complexity of the project you select, expect the final project to take about 10 hours to complete. After you have downloaded the appropriate module files folder for your operating system (PC or Macintosh) and have installed Geometer's Sketchpad, you are ready to begin. Proceed as follows:
Please note that each Lesson and Exercise referred to on this page, along with this Step-By-Step file, are in the dynamic.zip file attached at the bottom of this page.
|If you are not familiar with Geometer's Sketchpad, you should work through Using the Geometer's Sketchpad Module from Math Teacher Link or the Geometer's Sketchpad Introductory Lab from the Geometry Forum.|
|Complete this short set of homework exercises that will test your basic knowledge of geometry and of the Geometer's Sketchpad.|
|If you are enrolled for graduate or continuing education credit, submit Intro HWK through the Module Hand-In System using your MTL login and password before you go on to Step 2.|
|Work through each of the following lessons, using the accompanying Geometer's Sketchpad files. Each of these lessons has a corresponding homework assignment that should be handed in.
|If you are enrolled for graduate or continuing education credit, submit Lesson 1 Hwk through Lesson 5 Hwk as you complete them through the Module Hand-In System using your MTL login and password before you go on to Step 3.|
|Review the projects provided in the Projects folder in the download. This will give you some idea of how you can use Geometer's Sketchpad to develop your own teaching materials. Of course, you are welcome to use these projects, or items from them, in your own teaching. This should also give you some ideas for projects of your own. Often, you will be able to borrow and modify Sketchpad sketches and scripts from these projects for projects of your own.|
|If you are enrolled as an MTL guest or for Continuing Education Credit, you have just completed the module. Congratulations! Those of you enrolled for Continuing Education Credit will be sent feedback on the assignments that you were required to submit.
If you are enrolled in the module for Graduate Credit, you now have the opportunity to put your Sketchpad skills to work by creating an approved Final Project that you can use in your teaching. Proceed to Step 4 for help in selecting, completing and submitting your Final Project.
Select a Sketchpad project (or projects) that would be useful to you in your teaching. Notify us of your choice and give us a brief description of the project.
|We suggest that you choose something relatively simple for your first project - you can always tackle more complicated projects later after you have some confidence in your Sketchpad skills. Try to incorporate the kinds of ideas you have seen in the lessons -- moving configurations, tracing points, lines or circles, measuring selected quantities, etc. Your project could consist of a set of exercises with instructions as text areas right on a Sketchpad sketch or it could be a Word document containing the instructions accompanied by any necessary sketches, much as the lessons on this module were laid out. If you are comfortable with HTML you could even create a project much like the lessons in the module, but this is certainly not necessary.
Before you begin work on your Final Project, submit a brief outline to us by emailing email@example.com or your instructor directly. We may be able to make some helpful suggestions.
Complete your Final Project.
|You will need to submit an electonic copy of Final Proj through the Module Hand In System using your MTL login and password.
That's it folks! We believe that if you complete these steps, you will acquire the tools necessary to use the Geometer's Sketchpad, or a similar geometry package, actively in your teaching. You should also have gained the background necessary to learn more about this software as your needs dictate.
The term "dynamic" in mathematics refers to the ideas of motion and change. Dynamic Geometry is a new term coined in response to the new software packages such as Sketchpad and Cabri. These products act as a sort of electronic ruler and compass. What really sets a Sketchpad sketch apart from one that you might have made on a sheet of paper with the good old tools of our high school days is not just the accuracy of the constructions. It is the fact that the software remembers relationships among the various components of a construction --- that point P is the midpoint of the segment AB, that circle c has center O and goes through point X etc.
So, for instance, when you construct the circumcircle of a triangle (Open the file ex1_1.gsp found in the Examples folder in the download) you can move any of the vertices of the triangle and see that the circle still circumscribes the triangle. Try this by clicking on a vertex, holding down the mouse, and dragging the vertex around. Notice that you can make the center, O of the circumcircle either inside, outside, or on an edge of the triangle. Can you find a triangle where the circumcenter is at a vertex? What can you say about the triangles where the circumcenter is on one of the edges? These are the kinds of questions you can have students explore when they can see different instances of the same construction just by moving the initial objects (in this case the three vertices of the triangle).
Let's illustrate how we might guide a student to a simple discovery. Suppose we are trying to find the locus of all point X that are equidistant from points A and B.
We can start with a simple special case. Find all the points that are a given distance from both A and B. The points at distance d from A form a circle (center A and radius d) and the This means that the points at distance d from B form a circle (center B and radius d). Thus the points at distance d from both A and B will be the points of intersection of these two circles.
To illustrate this with a Sketchpad sketch (See file ex1_2.gsp in the Examples folder), you need the points A and B along with a segment whose length we can use for the distance d. On the sketch:
Now we are in the position to ask, "What happens if we change the distance d?" To answer this:
When you finish dragging the endpoint around, Sketchpad will connect the traced points with a "curve." This curve looks for all the world like a straight line, or perhaps two pieces of a straight line. What is the relationship between this line and the segment AB? To make sure that this is not a coincidence, move either A, or B, or both, then repeat the process of dragging an endpoint of the segment. Do you still appear to get a straight line?
At this point you could construct the perpendicular bisector of AB and check try dragging an endpoint again. You should see the traced points lying along this perpendicular bisector. In some sense, this is a proof of the result:
The locus of points equidistant from the two distinct points A and B is the perpendicular bisector of the segment AB.
You, of course, could proceed with a proof of this fact. That can be illustrated by other Sketchpad sketches, but the software can't do everything!!
At this point, let us examine a more sophisticated version (See file ex1_3.gsp) of the sketch we just used, and see how it was constructed. Notice that, in this version:
These are all quite simple enhancements. Try these steps on a new sketch.
Three of the four sketches for this section are actually from the examples that are distributed with Sketchpad itself. The first sketch for this section (See file ex1_4a.gsp) illustrates the formula for the area of a parallelogram. We are assuming that students believe the formula for the area of a rectangle. Area is actually a hard thing to define precisely and the formula for the area of a rectangle is often taken as one of the axioms of area.
This sketch presents a framework for experimentation and discovery, but it does not give any proof of the result it is looking for. The next sketch (See file ex1_4b.gsp) addresses the same issue, the formula for the area of a parallelogram, but it actually includes a proof a text box beneath the sketch. Obviously there are times when one approach is preferred over the other and vice versa.
The two sketches also vary somewhat in the number of objects that are hidden or shown. Remember that if you leave a point or a segment visible, the user can drag it. This movement may affect the way the sketch appears in a manner that does not contribute to its overall effect. The next sketch (See file ex1_5.gsp) illustrates the formula for the area of a trapezoid. The final sketch (See file ex1_6.gsp) illustrates the formula for the area of a triangle. You should experiment with all of these examples. Notice how nicely the sketches behave when the indicated point is dragged. The parallel lines don't move and just the right concept is illustrated. What happens if you move some of the other points in the sketches? These may seem like very simple sketches. Indeed, they are not too complicated, but it does take some practice to get them to behave as nicely as these do. You should try to replicate these sketches. If you are having trouble getting them to work properly, you might try going to the original and using Show All Hidden from the Display menu. This will show you what other objects were constructed and then hidden to make the sketch. It is not always easy to see what is going on, but it may help. If you have messed up the original, don't worry. Just close it without saving and open it again in its original condition! Be sure to contact us at firstname.lastname@example.org if you have trouble here. The techniques you discover here will be very helpful in creating good sketches of your own later.
Complete the exercises in Lesson 1 Homework and submit them to the MTL handin system.
Suppose we have a point X on a segment AB. This point divides the segment into two pieces: AX and XB. It is often important to know the ratio of the lengths of these two segments. this is sometimes referred to as the ratio into which X divides the segment AB. There are two common ways to measure this:
You can compute the ratio Length(AX)/Length(XB), which describes the relative sizes of the two pieces. If X is close to A this ratio is close to 0. As X moves along the segment towards B, the ratio gets increases. When X is at the midpoint of AB the ratio is exactly 1. As X gets closer and closer to B the ratio gets larger and larger, without bound.
You could also compute the ratio Length(AX)/Length(AB). This measures what fraction of the whole segment is taken up by AX. When X is close to A, this ratio is close to 0. Again, as X moves toward B the ratio increases. This time, however the ratio is 1/2 when X is at the midpoint and is 1 when X is at B.
Let us take some time to see how to display these ratios effectively in Sketchpad.
A dilation is a transformation that contracts (or expands) all points towards (away from) a given central point by a fixed ratio. Thus, to specify a dilation you have to specify the central point and the ratio. If the ratio is less than 1 then points will be pulled in towards the central point and all distances will shrink by the ratio. In other words, if two points P and Q were distance 6 apart and you applied a dilation with center C and ratio 1/3 then P would go to a point P' and Q would go to a point Q' where now the distance from P' to Q' would be 2.
Open the first sample sketch for this lesson (You will have downloaded it back in the first part of the Step-by-Step directions when you downloaded the file "dynamic.zip") and experiment with the results of a dilation. This sketch has defined a dilation centered at C with ratio determined by AX/XB. The three blue figures are the originals and the results of dilating them are colored in magenta. Try moving X to get different ratios and moving C to give the original figures a different position relative to the center. You can also change the shape and size of the original figures.
You should be able to make some simple conjectures about the relationship of a figure to its image after a dilation. For instance:
When you consider how you would complete these conjectures, fill in both the kind of figure (segment, circle, ellipse rectangle etc.), the shape (similar to the original, larger angles than the original etc.), and the size (relative to the original).
Now let's see if we can create an interesting dilation.
Notice that the dialog box refers to the ratio in terms of the New distance and the Old distances. In other words, the ratio of PY to PQ. But this is what we want to be the same as the ratio of AX to AB. This is a quantity we have already measured.
Save this sketch. You will need it in your homework assignment.
Complete the exercises in Lesson 2 homework and submit them to the MTL handin system.
This result deals with line segments that go from one vertex of a triangle to a point on the opposite side. In tribute to the Italian mathematician Giovanni Ceva, these are sometimes called cevians of the triangle. In the figure below, AW, AX, BY, and CZ (in red) are all examples of cevians for the triangle ABC (in blue).
Although the term cevian may be new to you, the concept is certainly not. You have seen examples. For instance, the medians, the altitudes, and the angle bisectors are examples of cevians.
You have probably noticed that, in each of these examples, the three cevians all go through a single point. Ceva's Theorem gives a condition that determines whether or not three cevians from the three vertices of a triangle will have this concurrency property.
Open the next sketch (See file ex3_1.gsp). This shows a generic triangle along with three cevians, one from each vertex. We have also included the ratios into which the endpoints of the cevians divide their corresponding sides of the triangle. Use this sketch to perform the following experiments. In each case, record the values for the ratios CX/XB, AY/YC, and BZ/ZA.
Can you see any pattern here?
By this stage you should have discovered:
If the three cevians AX, BY and CZ are concurrent, then the product of the ratios (CX/XB) (BZ/ZA) (AY/YC) = 1.
The ratios are taken in the same "order," that is, either all counterclockwise (as in the statement of the theorem above) or, equivalently, all clockwise. In the clockwise case the condition would be
(BX/XC) (CY/YA) (AZ/ZB) = 1.
First we should consider what we mean by the ratio in which a point divides a segment if the point is not actually inside the segment. This may sound kind of silly, but consider the following diagram.
where X is on the line determined by A and B but is not between them. Although you might well say that X does not divide the segment at all, you can still make perfectly good sense of the ratio AX/XB. In the picture below, the red segment is equal in length to AX and the blue on to XB
You can open a Sketchpad version of this ( See file ex3_2.gsp). Once you have done that, drag the point X along the line and observe the changes in the ratio.
Now we can create a sketch that will check Ceva's Theorem for more general cevians. Open a New Sketch. In this sketch:
Now you can drag X and Y along their respective lines and the three cevians should remain concurrent. What happens to the product of the ratios?
In other words, Ceva's Theorem is still true when the cevians do not all lie in the interior of the triangle.
To prove Ceva's Theorem in the case where all the cevians lie in the interior of the triangle, we have to show that if the Cevians are concurrent then the product of the ratios is 1. Use the point of concurrency, O, to form the three triangles (colored red, green, and blue in the figure below) AOC, COB, and BOA.
From your homework for Lesson 2, you know, for instance, that the ratio Area(COB)/Area(AOC) is equal to the ratio BZ/ZA. Using this, and similar equalities, you can complete the proof. This is one of your homework exercises.
Complete the exercises in Lesson 3 homework and submit them to the MTL handin system.
One of your prerequisite homework exercises was to construct a line tangent to a circle C through a point P outside the circle. The key here was to recall that the radial line (in red in the figure below) from the center, O, through the point of contact, X, is perpendicular to the tangent line (in blue).
Let's see how to create a dynamic sketch that should induce a student to discover how to use this fact to come up with the construction of the tangent line. This is another great use of the dynamic features of Sketchpad.
Open a new sketch and perform the following steps:
You have constructed a line, PQ, perpendicular to the radial line AO. Moreover, for this choice of A, Q is the only point that will make PQ perpendicular to the radial line AO. The only problem is that this line PQ is almost certainly not a tangent line! To find the tangent line, we need to choose a different radial line and hence a different perpendicular.
Try dragging point A, to get a new radial line, until Q sits right on the circle. At this point PQ will be the tangent line we are looking for. Unfortunately, this doesn't tell us how to make an accurate construction that will create the correct position of Q.
Now select Q and choose Trace Point from the Display menu. Then drag the point A completely around circle C. What is the locus traced by Q during this motion? What points does it go through? Is OP a diameter of this locus and why?
The answers to these questions should lead to the appropriate construction:
If you try this construction you will get both the tangent lines to C through P.
In this section we want to start with two circles, each one outside the other. We are looking for a line that is tangent to both these circles. If you try to draw the picture, you will see that there are essentially two different ways that this can happen. The line can touch each of the circles, with both of the circles on the same side of the line (the blue line in the figure below), or it can touch each of the circles with the circles on opposite sides of the line the red line in the figure below).
The first case (the blue line) is called an external common tangent for the two circles, while the other case (the red line) is called an internal tangent. In the rest of this lesson, we will only work with external common tangents. You will create similar constructions with internal common tangents in the homework exercises.
First, let us try a few experiments to try to draw the common external tangents to a pair of circles and see if they give us any hint as to how we might find a construction. Begin by opening a new sketch and drawing two circles, C and D, each outside the other. Pick any point P in the plane and draw the two tangents to circle C through P.
Now move P until the two lines are tangent to D as well as to C. Can you see anything about where P must be in relation to the two original circles? Try moving the circles and repeating to see if your idea still seems to hold.
Open a new sketch and draw two circles as before. Construct points X and Y on circle C and then draw the radial segments from the center of C to both X and Y. Draw lines perpendicular to each of these segments at X and Y respectively. By construction these must be tangent to C.
Move X and Y until you have found (at least approximately) the two common external tangents. What can you say about this configuration? Do the common tangents intersect? If so, do they intersect in a point on the line between the centers of the circles? If you knew the point of contact, X, of one common tangent, how could you find the point of contact, Y, of the other? Think of the symmetry of the picture.
If we have an external common tangent, then the two radii, one for each circle, out to the points of contact, must both be perpendicular to this line. This means that they must be parallel.
We could try to find the common tangent, then, by drawing parallel radii and joining their endpoints. Open a new sketch and draw the two circles as before. Draw a radius OX for circle C. Then draw a parallel line through the center O' of D and find its intersection, Y, with D so that you can draw a radius O'Y that is parallel to OX. Then construct the line joining X and Y.
This is probably not the common tangent that we are looking for. We will find that by changing the position of X. Drag X around circle C until you appear to have the common tangent.
We now have three different ways to get a pretty good approximation for the common tangent line. Unfortunately, none of these has yet given us a precise construction. In the final sketch you created, select the line XY and choose Trace Line from the Display menu. Now repeat the process of dragging X around circle C. What do you notice about the images of the line XY? Do they all go through a single point? If they do, then how could you find that point? Once you know how to locate this point, how can you use it to find the common external tangent(s)?
Answers to these questions give you a method for finding the external tangents.
The point of intersection of the two external common tangents is called the external center of similitude of the two circles.
Practice this construction several times until you are sure that you have it mastered. Do not hesitate to contact us for help if you are not sure about any step. It is essential that you understand this. Also, be sure that you hide all auxiliary lines and points. At the end of the construction the only new objects on your sketch should be the to tangent lines, their intersection point and their points of contact with the circles.
At this stage, it would be good practice to create a custom tool for this construction. Open a New Sketch from the File menu and draw two circles as usual. Complete the entire sketch, constructing the common tangents, and hiding the appropriate auxiliary constructions. Once the sketch is complete, do an Edit, Select All command, and then click on the Custom Tool button, selecting Create New Tool. Name the new tool "external center" and click on the box for Show Script View. You will now see a step by step listing of each of the actions you have taken to create the external centers of similitude. Check the beginning of your script to see what the Given requirements are for this script. This list will depend on how you did your construction, but it will probably contain at least the two circles and their centers. As described in the section on custom tools in Module 4, when you want to replicate this construction for any other two circles, you use the Custom Tool button, select the "external center" tool, and ask it to Show Script View. Then in the script view window, click on All Steps. This method will work particularly well as you do Lesson 4, Excercise 2 in the homework, where you need to create three different centers of similitude in the same drawing.
When you want to use the script, you need to select the corresponding objects on a sketch, in the order they appear in the Given list, and the click either PLAY or FAST on the script. Be sure to save your script. Then try it out a few times to make sure that you know how to use it and to make sure that it works correctly. There is no good way to edit scripts since they are just recordings of actions. If you need to make a correction or alteration, you need to start over again with a new recording of the script.
You should notice that as long as one circle is not completely inside the other and the circles do not have the same radius, then the construction works properly. What happens if the circles have the same radius? Is there a common tangent line(s)? What happens if one circle is inside the other?
This theorem has to do with what happens when we have three circles. Open the sample sketch for this lesson (See file ex4_1.gsp). It shows three circles c1, c2, and c3. The red lines are common tangents to c1 and c2, the blue lines the common tangents to c2 and c3, and the green lines the common tangents to c1 and c3. You can move the centers of any of the circles and adjust their radii by moving the points labeled A, B, or C.
Label the center of similitude of c1 and c2 as X, the center of similitude of c2 and c3 as Y and the center of similitude of c1 and c3 as Z. Do you notice any relationship among these three points X, Y, and Z? Move the configuration and see if this still seems to be the case.
The three centers of similitude appear to be collinear (lined up on a single straight line). How would you check that? Move the configuration and see if your check still holds. This is Monge's Theorem:
For three disjoint circles of unequal radii with no one circle contained in any other, the three external centers of similitude for the three pairs of circles are collinear.
Complete the exercises in Lesson 4 homework and submit them to the MTL handin system.
The medians of a triangle all intersect in a point (the centroid of the triangle). The same is true of the angle bisectors (the incenter), the altitudes (the orthocenter) and the perpendicular bisectors of the sides (the circumcenter). These are all examples of important "centers" for a triangle.
Use Sketchpad to construct each of these centers.
This is also referred to as the Toricelli Configuration. It consists of an equilateral triangle drawn outward from each side of a triangle. You can see an example in the accompanying sketch for this lesson (See file ex5_1.gsp).
In this sketch, P, Q, and R are the vertices of the equilateral triangles and X, Y, and Z are their centroids (which also happen to be the circumcenters, incenters and orthocenters!). Napoleon's Theorem states that the centers X, Y, and Z form an equilateral triangle. Join these points and measure the sides of the resulting triangle to verify this. Be sure to move the vertices around and see that this property holds in all cases.
Now delete those segments and join each center to the vertex of the original triangle that is opposite it. That is, draw the lines AX, BY, and CZ. Notice that these lines meet in a point. This point is called the First Napoleon Center for the triangle. Is it always inside the original triangle? If not, can you determine under what conditions it will be outside?
Delete these lines and construct the lines AP, BQ, and CR. These also meet in a point. This is called the First Brocard Point for the triangle. Is it always inside the triangle? If not, can you determine when it is outside? Construct this intersection point and label it O. Measure the angles AOB, BOC, and COA. What do you find? Does this hold when you change the original triangle?
Open a new sketch and draw an arbitrary triangle ABC. Draw the inscribed circle and construct the point, X, where this circle touches BC; Y where this circle touches AC; Z where this circle touches AB. Then draw the lines AX, BY, and CZ. They meet in the Gergonne Point.
Save this sketch. You will need it for your homework.
Let X be the point where the ex-circle opposite A touches BC; Y the point where the ex-circle opposite B touches AC; Z the point where the ex-circle opposite C touches AB.
The Nagel Point is the intersection of the lines AX, BY, and CZ. Beneath the figure for the Gergonne Point, create a figure for the Nagel point. Save the resulting sketch.
There are almost as many such centers as you can imagine. The homework exercises ask you to draw diagrams for a few more and to invent some of your own!
For instance, here are some interesting centers:
Complete the exercises in Lesson 5 homework and submit them to the MTL handin system.